About this propertyMLS® 1302800
52–54 Old Settlement Hill is a private, tucked-away property in Freshwater, Newfoundland and Labrador, offering an attractive elevated setting with ocean views and a sense of privacy above the surrounding community. The property includes an existing structure, but the building should be viewed primarily as a renovation or redevelopment opportunity. It will require either extensive repairs and rehabilitation or complete removal and replacement, depending on a buyer’s intended use and assessment of the structure.
Property details
More details
Overview
The home
Systems & utilities
Taxes
Features
Fees & source
Rooms
Freshwater at a glance
Live market stats for Freshwater: what's for sale, what it costs, how it compares to nearby towns, and how walkable this address is.
Homes for sale here
8
Median list price
$65k
Price range
$25k – $1.1M
Typical build
1990
Average size
1,306 sqft
Where Freshwater listings are priced
Every active list price in Freshwater, grouped into bands.
List price, thousands of $ · 8 homes
View as table
| Price band ($) | Listings |
|---|---|
| <200 | 7 |
| 1M+ | 1 |
How Freshwater compares
Median list price against the next biggest markets. Click a row for that area guide.
Neighbourhood scores
Walk, bike, and transit scores for this exact address.
Explore Freshwater on Walk ScoreLocation, air, flood & taxes
Elevation
73 m
0300 mmetres above sea level
Air quality now
1–3 band
110+AQHI 2 · Low risk · St. John's · updated 7:30 p.m.
Flood & zoning are mapped for St. John's only
Property tax
$900 / year
≈ $75 / month
Amenity constellation
compass view · OpenStreetMap · ODEF schools
Nearby & drive routes
5 places shown · OpenStreetMap · OSRM
Schools 1
Groceries 1
Parks 3
What this home really costs
Winter heat, five years of ownership, how this price sits against the market, and what the map says is within walking distance: every figure captioned with its assumptions.
5-year cost of ownership
20% down · 25-yr
5-year all-in: $36,537
Closing costs + five years of running costs + 60 mortgage payments on a $60,000 home.
If rates rise 2 points
$3,493 more over five years if the rate is 6.84% instead of 4.84% (P&I only).
Once, at closing
- Land transfer (registration) fee$100 + $0.40 per $100 over $500, capped at $5,000$338
- Legal feesest.estimate, your lawyer quotes the exact figure$1,500
- Down payment (20%)$12,000
Every year
- Heatingest.2× the Jan–Mar estimate (heating season ≈ 6 months)$1,626
- Property taxfrom the feed$900
- Home insuranceest.estimate, NL range $700–$1,500/yr$1,100
× 5 years = $18,130
By down payment
| Down | Payment | 5-yr all-in | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5% | $328 | $39,643 | needs mortgage insurance (not modelled) |
| 10% | $311 | $38,608 | needs mortgage insurance (not modelled) |
| 20% | $276 | $36,537 | no mortgage insurance |
Estimates, not a quote or an appraisal. Mortgage at 4.84% (lowest bank 5-yr fixed, Ratehub.ca, 2026-11-20), 25-year amortization, P&I only. Land transfer fee: Registry of Deeds schedule ($100 + $0.40/$100 over $500, cap $5,000). Legal $1,500 and insurance $1,100/yr (NL range $700–$1,500) are estimates. Heating is 2× the Jan–Mar winter estimate. 5-year all-in = closing costs + 5 years of running costs + 60 mortgage payments; it excludes CMHC insurance (needed below 20% down), utilities other than heat, and maintenance.
More cost & context panels
Rate time machine
same house · same down payment
Same house, same down payment: your payment today at 4.84%lowest bank rate · posted was 6.19%
- Today, lowest bank rate2026-11-20 · 4.84%$276/mo
- Today, posted2026-11-18 · 6.19%$315/mo
- 5 years ago2021-11-03 · 4.79%$275/mo
- 10 years ago2016-11-02 · 4.64%$271/mo
At 6.19%, five years ago, the same mortgage would have cost $39 more each month than at today's posted rate.
Principal & interest only: $48,000 (80% of the $60,000 asking price, 20% down), 25-year amortization. No taxes, insurance, fees, or mortgage insurance. Today's rate is the Bank of Canada conventional 5-year rate observed 2026-11-18. The 5- and 10-year rows are two documented observations of that same series (2021-11-03 = 4.79%, 2016-11-02 = 4.64%, retrieved 2026-11-01 from bankofcanada.ca/valet), fixed reference points, not a modelled path between them. Estimate, not an offer of credit; your lender's rate will differ.
Errand score
walk-time weighted
11
grocery 840 m
Nearest errand: Fort Saint Louis Historic Park (park), 810 m, about 10 min on foot.
Walk-time-weighted from OpenStreetMap + ODEF school data; straight-line distance at 4.8 km/h. Weights: grocery 1.0, school 0.9, health 0.8, park 0.4, café 0.35, bus 0.3; nearest place per category only. Half-value every 6 minutes of walking; nothing scores past a 15-minute walk. 100 = every category at the door. This is a mapping of what's drawn on the map, not a survey of what exists.
Ask this listing
open data · 3 questions
- School within 1 km?No school mapped within 1 km
- Grocery nearby?Yes · 840 mSuper1Stop
- Bus stop?No bus stop mapped within 800 m
From OpenStreetMap + ODEF schools (straight-line distance) and the City of St. John's flood & zoning maps. Flood and zoning are mapped for St. John's only; elsewhere those questions don't appear because we don't know the answer.
Monthly carrying cost
$328/mo
Calculators
Estimate payments and returns before you make an offer, all in one place.
Mortgage & investment calculator
Estimated monthly payment
$75/mo
Principal & interest $0 + property tax $75 per month
Financing breakdown
Investment calculator
Monthly cash flow
$-75
NOI / month
$-75
Cap rate
-1.50%
Gross yield
0.00%
| Line item | Monthly | Yearly |
|---|---|---|
| Gross rent | $0 | $0 |
| Mortgage | $0 | $0 |
| Property tax | $75 | $900 |
| Expenses | $0 | $0 |
| Vacancy | $0 | $0 |
| Management | $0 | $0 |
| Cash flow | $-75 | $-900 |
| NOI | $-75 | $-900 |
Flip rule of thumb: buy at ≤ 70% of ARV minus repair costs.
Have a question?
Send a message and Haris will get back to you — usually the same day.
Talk to Haris
Buying, selling, or just curious about what your home is worth — no call centres, no runaround.
- Call or text416-873-4676
- Emailharis@barki.co
- Office17 Duffy Place, Suite 200, St. John's
Keller Williams Platinum Realty


