Skip to content

210 Pennywell Road

St. John's, NL, A1C2L6

location
3,136 sqft182 days on market

List price

$399,900

Haris Barki
Haris Barki
REALTOR® · Keller Williams Platinum Realty

About this propertyMLS® 1297894

For Sale at $399,900 or for lease at $5500 POU. Ideal owner-operator restaurant opportunity in the center of St. John's. Operating as the well-known New City Restaurant, this high-visibility property successfully served the community for more than 25 years and offers outstanding potential for a wide range of future uses. Ideally located just moments from downtown, Ropewalk Lane, Memorial University, the Avalon Mall, major amenities, and key transportation routes, this property combines convenience, exposure, and long-term upside in one strategic location. The longstanding restaurant operation may support future discretionary commercial use opportunities subject to City approvals, while the existing layout and history provide an excellent foundation for a purchaser looking to bring new life and vision to the space. Currently zoned R2, the property also presents significant redevelopment and residential intensification potential. The building includes a spacious 6-bedroom apartment, creating additional income potential for investors or flexibility for owner occupancy, staff accommodations, or future redevelopment concepts. Whether you're an entrepreneur, investor, restaurateur, or developer, this property offers exceptional value and upside potential in a rapidly evolving area of the city. The property is being offered in its current condition and presents an excellent opportunity for purchasers looking to renovate, reposition, or customize the property to suit their vision. Rarely do opportunities with this combination of location, history, zoning flexibility, and future potential become available. Note - basement not included in total square footage. Please see the 3d tour.

Property details

Size3,136 sqft
Property tax$6,995 / year
HeatingBaseboard heaters, Electric
Price per sq ft$128
More details

Overview

Address210 Pennywell Road, St. John's, Newfoundland & Labrador, Canada A1C2L6
StatusActive
Last updatedabout 2 months ago ( Oct 2, 2026 )

The home

Property TypeRetail
Building typeCommercial Mix

Systems & utilities

HeatingBaseboard heaters, Electric

Size & land

Living area3,136 square feet
Price per sq ft$128

Taxes

Property tax$6,995 / year
Tax year2026

Features

OwnershipFreehold
Intended useOther

Fees & source

Rooms

St. John's at a glance

Live market stats for St. John's: what's for sale, what it costs, how it compares to nearby towns, and how walkable this address is.

Full St. John's area guide

Homes for sale here

425

Median list price

$400k

Price range

$65k – $4.3M

Typical build

1976

Average size

3,749 sqft

Where St. John's listings are priced

Every active list price in St. John's, grouped into bands.

0
50
100
<200200–300300–400400–500500–750750–1M1M+

List price, thousands of $ · 353 homes

View as table
Price band ($)Listings
<20039
200–30055
300–40081
400–50047
500–75065
750–1M30
1M+36

How St. John's compares

Median list price against the next biggest markets. Click a row for that area guide.

Neighbourhood scores

Walk, bike, and transit scores for this exact address.

Walk Score for 210 Pennywell RoadBike Score for 210 Pennywell RoadTransit Score for 210 Pennywell Road
Explore St. John's on Walk Score

Location, air, flood & taxes

Flood (100-yr)

Out

outside the mapped floodplain

Zoning

R2R2

1.20 ha parcel

Elevation

83 m

0300 m

metres above sea level

Air quality now

1–3 band

110+

AQHI 2 · Low risk · St. John's · updated 4:30 p.m.

City of St. John's flood & zoning maps · NRCan elevation model · ECCC AQHI

Property tax

$6,995 / year

≈ $583 / month · assessment year 2026

Climate

Feb -1° · Jul 21°

normal daily high · ST JOHN'S A station · 1981–2010

Amenity constellation

compass view · OpenStreetMap · ODEF schools

Schools 43Health 1Groceries 16Cafés 8Parks 15Bus stops 25
108 places within 1.5 km · north is up · bus stops collected to 0.8 km (dashed ring)

Nearby & drive routes

108 places shown · OpenStreetMap · OSRM

Schools 43

Health 1

Groceries 16

Cafés 8

Parks 15

Bus stops 25

What this home really costs

Winter heat, five years of ownership, how this price sits against the market, and what the map says is within walking distance: every figure captioned with its assumptions.

5-year cost of ownership

20% down · 25-yr

5-year all-in: $174,514

Closing costs + five years of running costs + 60 mortgage payments on a $399,900 home.

If rates rise 2 points

$174,514$197,798

$23,284 more over five years if the rate is 6.84% instead of 4.84% (P&I only).

Once, at closing

  • Land transfer (registration) fee$100 + $0.40 per $100 over $500, capped at $5,000$1,698
  • Legal feesest.estimate, your lawyer quotes the exact figure$1,500
  • Down payment (20%)$79,980

Every year

  • Heatingest.2× the Jan–Mar estimate (heating season ≈ 6 months)$4,082
  • Property taxfrom the feed$6,995
  • Home insuranceest.estimate, NL range $700–$1,500/yr$1,100

× 5 years = $60,885

By down payment

DownPayment5-yr all-inNote
5%$2,186$195,220needs mortgage insurance (not modelled)
10%$2,071$188,318needs mortgage insurance (not modelled)
20%$1,841$174,514no mortgage insurance

Estimates, not a quote or an appraisal. Mortgage at 4.84% (lowest bank 5-yr fixed, Ratehub.ca, 2026-11-20), 25-year amortization, P&I only. Land transfer fee: Registry of Deeds schedule ($100 + $0.40/$100 over $500, cap $5,000). Legal $1,500 and insurance $1,100/yr (NL range $700–$1,500) are estimates. Heating is 2× the Jan–Mar winter estimate. 5-year all-in = closing costs + 5 years of running costs + 60 mortgage payments; it excludes CMHC insurance (needed below 20% down), utilities other than heat, and maintenance.

Price ghosts

$/sqft vs 298 active

Priced at the 9th percentile of active St. John's homes

$128/sqft, city median $197/sqft.

this home
this home · $128/sqftmedian · $197/sqft298 active St. John's listings with a price and a living area · estimate, not an appraisal

Winter warmer

Jan–Mar · estimate

$680/mo

Est. winter heating (electricity): about $2,041 for January through March.

Climate severity 1.00× St. John's3,136 sqft

Estimate, not an appraisal. electricity at 15.587¢/kWh (Newfoundland Power, eff. Jul 1 2026, pre-HST). 3,136 sqft. Severity 1.00× St. John's from the ST JOHN'S A station 1981–2010 normal. Jan–Mar only; excludes HST, hot water, cooking and any cooling.

More cost & context panels

Rate time machine

same house · same down payment

Same house, same down payment: your payment today at 4.84%lowest bank rate · posted was 6.19%

  • Today, lowest bank rate2026-11-20 · 4.84%$1,841/mo
  • Today, posted2026-11-18 · 6.19%$2,099/mo
  • 5 years ago2021-11-03 · 4.79%$1,831/mo
  • 10 years ago2016-11-02 · 4.64%$1,804/mo

At 6.19%, five years ago, the same mortgage would have cost $258 more each month than at today's posted rate.

Principal & interest only: $319,920 (80% of the $399,900 asking price, 20% down), 25-year amortization. No taxes, insurance, fees, or mortgage insurance. Today's rate is the Bank of Canada conventional 5-year rate observed 2026-11-18. The 5- and 10-year rows are two documented observations of that same series (2021-11-03 = 4.79%, 2016-11-02 = 4.64%, retrieved 2026-11-01 from bankofcanada.ca/valet), fixed reference points, not a modelled path between them. Estimate, not an offer of credit; your lender's rate will differ.

Errand score

walk-time weighted

62

grocery 260 m, school 110 m

0100

Nearest errand: Bishop Abraham Elementary (St. John's) (school), 110 m, about 1 min on foot.

Walk-time-weighted from OpenStreetMap + ODEF school data; straight-line distance at 4.8 km/h. Weights: grocery 1.0, school 0.9, health 0.8, park 0.4, café 0.35, bus 0.3; nearest place per category only. Half-value every 6 minutes of walking; nothing scores past a 15-minute walk. 100 = every category at the door. This is a mapping of what's drawn on the map, not a survey of what exists.

Ask this listing

open data · 5 questions

  • School within 1 km?Yes · 110 mBishop Abraham Elementary (St. John's)
  • Grocery nearby?Yes · 260 mOrangestore
  • Bus stop?Yes · 370 mFreshwater Rd at Keane Pl
  • In the 100-year floodplain?No, outside itCity of St. John's flood map
  • Zoning?R2: R21.20 ha parcel

From OpenStreetMap + ODEF schools (straight-line distance) and the City of St. John's flood & zoning maps. Flood and zoning are mapped for St. John's only; elsewhere those questions don't appear because we don't know the answer.

Monthly carrying cost

$2,269/mo

principal & interest at 4.84% (see calculator)$1,686property tax$583
Principal & interest assumes 20% down, 30-year amortization at 4.84%. Adjust it in the calculator above. Property tax from the 2026 assessment. No association fee on record.

Ask about 210 Pennywell Road

Book a showing, ask a question, or request the full listing package. Haris replies personally, usually the same day.

Your details go straight to Haris — never shared, never spammed.

Calculators

Estimate payments and returns before you make an offer, all in one place.

Mortgage & investment calculator

Estimated monthly payment

$583/mo

Rate 4.84%Term 30 yrDown 20% ($79,980)Tax $583/mo

Principal & interest $0 + property tax $583 per month

$
%
yrs
$
%
$
$

Financing breakdown

First mortgage$319,920
CMHC insurance premium$0
Total financing$319,920
Closing costs (est. 1.5%)$5,999
Cash to close(down payment + closing)$85,979
Total interest over term$-399,900
Property tax/mo$583
Yearly payments+ tax$6,995

Investment calculator

$
$
%
%

Monthly cash flow

$-582

NOI / month

$-582

Cap rate

-1.75%

Gross yield

0.00%

Line itemMonthlyYearly
Gross rent$0$0
Mortgage$0$0
Property tax$583$6,995
Expenses$0$0
Vacancy$0$0
Management$0$0
Cash flow$-582$-6,984
NOI$-582$-6,984
After-repair value (ARV)$571,286

Flip rule of thumb: buy at ≤ 70% of ARV minus repair costs.

Have a question?

Send a message and Haris will get back to you — usually the same day.

Haris Barki

Talk to Haris

Buying, selling, or just curious about what your home is worth — no call centres, no runaround.

Haris Barki, REALTOR®
Keller Williams Platinum Realty

Your details go straight to Haris — never shared, never spammed.